8 साल की शादी, सिर्फ 17 दिन साथ: पत्नी का खुलासा

Speedy Summary

• The Bombay High Court has refused to allow a potency test on a man, eight years after his marriage.
• The court overturned a Family Court decision that had granted the wife’s request for the medical examination. Justice Madhav Jamdar stated that aging could impact test outcomes and deemed such an examination legally inappropriate after this time lapse.
• The couple married in June 2017 but lived together for onyl 17 days. In October 2017, the wife sought annulment under the Hindu Marriage Act, claiming her husband was impotent and requested his medical evaluation.
• A Civil Hospital in Satara lacked experts for the tests at that time; hence, a Family Court directed Pune’s Sassoon Hospital to conduct them in May 2019.
• An August 2019 report concluded there were no indications of impotence or inability for physical relations based on expert analysis submitted to the family Court later.
• The High Court reasoned that human behavior and sexual responses change with age, making fresh tests unreliable after eight years.

Indian opinion Analysis
The bombay High Court’s refusal underscores procedural prudence and considerations of scientific reliability over emotional appeals within matrimonial disputes. Its stance emphasizes how aging and biological changes could lead to ambiguous results if tests are conducted long after events in question-reinforcing legal integrity while preventing misuse of medical examinations as tools for conflict resolution years later.

This ruling also potentially sets precedence on how personal disputes involving sensitive claims like impotence shoudl adhere strictly to timelines rooted in fairness and objective verification standards without extending undue emotional duress over extended durations post-marriage dissolution proceedings.

Read More