SC Declines Plea for Air India Safety Audit, Questions Exclusion of Other Airlines

Quick Summary

• The Supreme Court of India on August 8, 2025, declined a plea requesting an examination of Air India’s safety regulatory mechanisms following a crash at Ahmedabad airport on June 12 that involved its London-bound flight carrying 242 passengers and crew.
• Justice Surya Kant questioned the petitioner, N.K. Goswami, for exclusively targeting Air India rather than including other airlines in his petition.
• Mr. Goswami argued that he himself had been affected by a previous incident with Air India.
• The petitioner sought directives to establish an independent committee headed by a retired Supreme Court judge to investigate Air India’s safety practices and protocols within three months.
• He also requested an international aviation safety audit of Air India’s fleet by an ICAO-accredited agency addressing deficiencies highlighted in the 2024 ICAO audit report within six months.
• The petitioner ultimately withdrew his plea.

Image Description:

1. A representative image of an Air India Airbus A320 aircraft (Photo Credit: reuters).
2. Another related image with no specific description provided.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The Supreme Court’s decision reflects caution against targeting individual airlines based on isolated incidents without broader evidence implicating systemic issues across the industry. While the tragedy involving Air India’s London-bound flight necessitates scrutiny into aviation safety standards,prioritizing neutrality ensures fairness in evaluating regulatory mechanisms applicable to all carriers uniformly.

A complete approach such as sector-wide reviews rather than singling out one airline coudl bolster confidence in domestic aviation amid public concerns about passenger welfare after recent events. Though, any targeted audits remain critical if pointed shortcomings or patterns from prior assessments exist specifically affecting one operator’s operations and maintenance protocols-provided they are pursued objectively.

maintaining balanced vigilance over all airlines through independent oversight will uphold safer skies for passengers while fostering transparency within Indian civil aviation systems moving forward.

Read more: Link