Supreme Court to Notify Union, State Govts in Presidential Reference Case; Hearing Set for Mid-August

Fast Summary:

• A Constitution Bench of the Supreme court, led by Chief Justice of india (CJI) B.R. Gavai, announced that it will issue notices to the Union Government and State Governments regarding a presidential reference hearing on July 22, 2025.
• The hearing pertains to whether the Court can impose timelines and prescribe guidelines for Governors and the President when addressing State Bills sent for assent or reserved for consideration.
• The Bench includes CJI B.R. Gavai and Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P.S. Narasimha, and A.S. Chandurkar.
• The matter is scheduled to be heard in mid-August.
• Legal representatives for Tamil Nadu and Kerala raised concerns about the maintainability of the presidential reference.
• Attorney General of India has agreed to assist in proceedings.

Read More

Indian Opinion Analysis:

The Supreme Court’s decision to issue notices regarding this presidential query illustrates its proactive approach in addressing constitutional ambiguities concerning governance processes between States, Governors, and higher offices such as the President. By keeping “all questions open,” it signals an intent for thorough deliberation without predetermined conclusions.

This case could have significant implications for federal relations within India’s constitutional framework if resolved definitively. It may clarify procedural expectations surrounding bill approvals at both state and national levels while balancing accountability across executive roles like that of Governors and Presidents.

Involving diverse perspectives-from States like tamil Nadu contesting judgments grounded in past case law (April 8 Governor ruling),Kerala questioning procedural validity,alongside assistance from India’s Attorney General-ensures thorough analysis of competing legal interpretations essential for crafting a stable precedent.