BJP Calls SC Order on Aadhaar Use in Bihar SIR a Clarification, Not a Verdict on Policy

Quick Summary

• The Supreme Court directed the election Commission to allow the use of Aadhaar for voters in Bihar to challenge their omission from electoral rolls under the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).
• BJP president J.P. Nadda stated on X that Congress faced “disappointment” in court proceedings regarding SIR and labeled their reactions as “moral victories over non-issues.”
• BJP’s Amit Malviya termed the court’s order as procedural guidance and clarified that Aadhaar was requested only for identity verification, not citizenship.
• Congress described the directive as a “beacon of hope” in ensuring electoral fairness.

indian Opinion Analysis

The Supreme Court’s clarification offers procedural reinforcement to Bihar’s SIR process by enabling excluded voters to contest omissions using Aadhaar for identification purposes. While this emphasizes stronger safeguards against disenfranchisement, it does not modify existing protocols on citizenship or voter eligibility.Political statements that frame such judicial clarifications as defeats or victories reflect entrenched partisan narratives rather than substantive changes in policy outcomes. For India, this decision underscores the importance of checks in major revision exercises like SIR and signals a move toward more inclusive mechanisms ensuring clarity within democratic frameworks.

Read more at The Hindu