Calcutta HC’s Justice Tirthankar Ghosh Recuses From Hearing R.G. Kar Incident Case

Swift Summary

• Incident details: Parents of the R.G.Kar Medical College and Hospital rape and murder victim filed a petition seeking a fresh probe into alleged inconsistencies in the investigation conducted by the CBI.
• Judicial update: Calcutta High Court Justice Tirthankar Ghosh recused himself from hearing the petition,suggesting judicial consistency as two related petitions are being heard by another bench.
• Victim’s family stance: The parents expressed dissatisfaction with the CBI’s investigation, alleging it failed to uncover all involved parties beyond sole accused Sanjoy Roy (named in chargesheet).
• Political commentary: At Trinamool Congress Chhatra Parishad foundation day event, Abhishek Banerjee criticized CBI’s handling of the case compared to Kolkata Police, emphasizing swift action taken by state police under Mamata Banerjee’s leadership.
• Policy critique: Banerjee also mentioned central government opposition to TMC’s proposed “Aparajita Bill,” which sought capital punishment for rape cases leading to death or severe injury.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The developments surrounding the R.G. Kar Medical College incident highlight key legal and political concerns.The recusal of Justice Ghosh citing judicial consistency underscores efforts to ensure impartiality in sensitive cases but also raises questions about delays that effect victim families seeking justice. Divergent stances between state-administered police (Kolkata Police) and federally-run investigative agencies like CBI appear politically charged; however, such disagreements may inadvertently weaken confidence in investigations.

Abhishek Banerjee linking investigative shortcomings with broader policy disputes adds further complexity, reflecting systemic challenges within India’s criminal justice framework where laws governing punishment remain contested across ideological lines.

Read more: Link