Karnataka High Court Calls for Strict Enforcement of PoP Idol Ban

Quick Summary

• The karnataka High Court emphasized the need for the State government to seriously implement its ban on the manufacture, distribution, and sale of Plaster of Paris (PoP) idols.
• A division bench comprising Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice C.M. Joshi issued the order while disposing of a petition by the Karnataka State Pollution Control board (KSPCB).
• The KSPCB had sought directions for strict enforcement of a September 15, 2023 notification that banned PoP idols.
• The court declined to pass new directions, stating it is up to state authorities to enforce their own already issued ban order.
• Despite enforcement action such as sealing a PoP idol manufacturing unit in Kumbalgodu near Kengeri, incidents were reported where idols continued to be removed for sale clandestinely.
• Government counsel informed the bench that an FIR was registered regarding violations at this unit and further actions are ongoing.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The Karnataka High Court’s remarks underline a broader challenge with policy implementation in India-effective enforcement often lags behind legislative intent. While orders banning environmentally harmful practices like manufacturing PoP idols are steps towards sustainability, accountability mechanisms appear insufficient when violations persist post-ban. Reports of clandestine operations despite physical closures highlight gaps in monitoring and punitive measures.

This case also emphasizes coordination challenges between regulatory bodies like KSPCB and enforcement wings within administrative departments. Moving forward, stringent penalties alongside proactive surveillance could bolster compliance on this matter. On balance, such judicial oversight offers an crucial reminder that environmental protection demands not just laws but consistent request backed by administrative diligence.

Read More: