Madras High Court Directs Health Secretary to Probe T.N. Kidney Sale Racket

Quick Summary

• Event: Madras High court directed Tamil Nadu Health Secretary to investigate the alleged involvement of perambalur-based Dhanalakshmi Srinivasan Medical College and Hospital in an illegal kidney sale racket.
• Court Case: Two writ petitions were filed by the hospital against orders cancelling its renal transplant license following an August 10 press release and subsequent cancellation order on August 18.
• Inquiry Ordered: Justice N. Anand Venkatesh mandated a detailed inquiry, allowing all relevant parties (including the petitioner) to be heard, with a report due October 6.
• Status of Operations: The hospital’s advocate assured that no renal transplant surgeries would be conducted until court resolution; though, dialysis procedures are permitted at the institution.
• Controversy Background: Allegations surfaced after a Tamil TV news channel interviewed individuals claiming they had donated kidneys under questionable circumstances involving private hospitals. A defamation suit was filed by Dhanalakshmi Srinivasan against this channel.
• Government Action: Initial suspension led to full cancellation of the hospital’s renal transplant licence based on findings from a Health Department committee investigating illegal kidney sale practices.

Indian Opinion Analysis

This case highlights critical concerns about medical ethics and regulatory oversight in India’s healthcare system. Tamil nadu has been proactive in addressing organ trafficking,demonstrated by swift action in suspending and cancelling licences were allegations arose. However, questions regarding procedural fairness remain pivotal as the petitioner challenged actions taken without resolving pending appeals.

The madras High Court’s directive for impartial examination ensures transparency while balancing accountability with due process-an approach crucial for public trust in india’s medical institutions. Given organ donation’s importance to public health policy, stringent checks are necessary across hospitals nationwide to deter unethical practices without discouraging legitimate transplantation activities.

Read more: madras High Court directs inquiry into alleged illegal kidney sale racket