SC on Stray Dogs: Celebrities Criticise Decision, Call It ‘Soulless

Swift summary

• The Supreme court has ordered the relocation of stray dogs in Delhi-NCR to designated shelters.
• Celebrities including Zeenat Aman, Sonakshi Sinha, Varun Dhawan, Janhvi Kapoor, Rupali Ganguly, Shriya Pilgaonkar, and Shalini Pandey have criticized the decision publicly.
• Zeenat Aman called for a “humane” and “science-backed approach.”
• sonakshi Sinha referred to the judgment as evidence of a “soulless society.”
• Varun Dhawan and Janhvi Kapoor reshared posts claiming the decision was akin to a “death sentence for dogs.”
• Rupali Ganguly emphasized cultural significance and practical roles of stray dogs in Indian traditions.
• Shriya Pilgaonkar advocated community-driven sterilization and vaccination instead of removal due to overcrowded shelters nationwide.
• Shalini Pandey highlighted inadequate preventive measures like sterilization as core issues within current management.

Indian opinion Analysis

The Supreme Court’s mandate for relocating stray dogs reflects an attempt to balance urban safety concerns with animal welfare. However, overwhelming criticism from public figures highlights doubts about implementation efficacy. Celebrities stress that uprooting strays disregards shelter limitations in India and could result in neglect or harm during captivity.

The matter underscores larger systemic gaps like ineffective sterilization programs and lack of resources for humane coexistence initiatives. This pushback also raises broader ethical questions about balancing civic safety with compassion. Moving forward, a reconsidered policy prioritizing community-based solutions-vaccination drives or localized care-could achieve sustainable impact over forced eradication strategies.

Read More