Supreme Court: No Immediate Ban on Overage Vehicles

Quick Summary

• supreme Court Relief: The Supreme Court has directed that no coercive action be taken against owners of overage vehicles (over 15 years for petrol, 10 years for diesel) while it re-examines its 2018 order that banned such vehicles.
• Government Plea: Delhi government, represented by SG Tushar Mehta and ASG Aishwarya Bhati, appealed to the court to revoke the 2018 order, arguing it caused needless hardships and that pollution is not solely linked to vehicle age due to advances in technology like BS-VI emission norms.
• Proposed Alternative: The government suggested implementing a graded, data-driven policy based on actual vehicular emissions rather than blanket bans on older vehicles.
• Individual Petition: A senior citizen owner of a compliant but old vehicle also contested the blanket ban as arbitrary and non-scientific.
• SC Response: The SC issued notices, returnable in four weeks, and temporarily suspended any coercive actions against overage vehicle owners.

read More

Indian Opinion Analysis

This development reflects an important balancing act between curbing environmental pollution and addressing public grievances related to blanket legislative measures. While air pollution remains a critical issue in Delhi NCR region, the courtS willingness to revisit its earlier judgment signals recognition of technological advancements like BS-VI compliance and equity concerns among responsible citizens affected by rigid policies.

A scientific approach focusing on actual emissions instead of arbitrary age-related bans could provide more precision in reducing pollution without unnecessarily inconveniencing individuals or disrupting livelihoods. Though,such policies would require robust infrastructure for emission testing and vigilant enforcement mechanisms. This case could set a precedent for designing more effective environmental regulations across India.