TMC MP Sparks Debate in Rajya Sabha with Remarks on Amit Shah

quick Summary:

• Event: The Rajya Sabha discussion on the working of the home ministry turned contentious on Wednesday.
• Key Points:

– TMC MP Saket Gokhale criticized Home minister Amit Shah and alleged misuse of central agencies like CBI and NIA to target opposition-led state governments.
– Gokhale accused the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) of sidelining state authorities, citing examples such as expanded BSF jurisdiction in Bengal and Punjab.
– He claimed Bengal is poorly treated regarding central funds and referenced delayed approval for a bill addressing sexual violence passed by west Bengal’s assembly.
– Amit Shah responded,asserting that some accusations were factually incorrect-specifically regarding CBI cases-clarifying many were related to poll violence as directed by courts.

• Outcome: Chairman Jagdeep Dhankhar repeatedly intervened, declaring parts of Gokhale’s remarks “unparliamentary” and called for their expunction. A ruling will follow Thursday.

!Fireworks in Rajya Sabha after TMC MP targets Amit Shah

Indian Opinion Analysis:

The exchange underscores intensifying political tensions between the Union government and opposition parties within parliamentary debates. Criticisms leveled by Saket Gokhale reflect concerns from states over perceived federal overreach by central agencies, a recurring theme in Indian politics. On one side, allegations involving expanded BSF jurisdiction or delays in legislative approvals signal calls for greater autonomy at the state level. Conversely, Amit Shah’s clarification emphasizes adherence to judiciary directives concerning poll violence cases-a reminder that legal interventions may sometimes bypass state authority.

this debate highlights a broader struggle to balance federalism with national governance structures. Transparency around agency roles and equitable distribution of resources could mitigate mistrust while fostering healthier inter-governmental collaboration moving forward.

Read More