
Former India wicketkeeper Dinesh Karthik has said the team management has moved past Mohammed Shami and there is no point recalling him for the 2027 ODI World Cup. 'No. I feel there are other pacers, India have moved beyond him so there's no point in going back,' Karthik said on Cricbuzz on Monday, 5 October. Shami last played for India in the Champions Trophy 2025 final and has since been ignored despite strong domestic performances for Bengal, including his 100th first-class match in the Duleep Trophy final. The comments follow India's series win against the West Indies, where the pace attack conceded heavily, with West Indies chasing 352 in the third ODI on 4 October.

Former chief selector Ajit Agarkar had cited fitness concerns for dropping Shami, which the pacer publicly disputed. Agarkar has now completed his tenure. Ravichandran Ashwin said on his YouTube channel that Agarkar's exit opens the door for Shami. Multiple outlets report Bhuvneshwar Kumar's T20I comeback after four years, buoyed by IPL performances, as a possible template. Khelnow.com reports unverified claims that Shami could be considered for the ODI series against New Zealand starting 4 November. The BCCI is expected to announce the ODI squad shortly.
Update, 8 October 2026: New reports from sources published on 7 October 2026 suggest Shami could be reconsidered. Hindustan Times quotes Ravichandran Ashwin saying the door is not shut after Ajit Agarkar's exit as chief selector. Khelnow.com reports unverified claims of a possible recall for the New Zealand ODI series starting 4 November. Rediff.com and India Today compare Shami's domestic consistency with Bhuvneshwar Kumar's India comeback.
Khelnow.com reports Shami could be in contention for the New Zealand ODIs starting November 4, citing unverified claims, while Hindustan Times quotes Ravichandran Ashwin saying the exit of Ajit Agarkar as chief selector opens a door. Rediff.com and India Today draw a parallel with Bhuvneshwar Kumar's comeback based on IPL success but note Shami's weaker IPL record. NDTV, Times Now, News9, and the earlier Hindustan Times report focus on Dinesh Karthik's verdict that India has moved beyond Shami. The key difference is that Karthik's dismissal, from 5 October, is challenged by subsequent reports of possible reconsideration. India's ODI squad for the New Zealand series is expected to be announced shortly, which will settle the question of Shami's return.
Coverage: 10 sources, 9 neutral, 1 sensationalist
Sources (10): ndtv.com (neutral report), timesnownews.com (neutral report), news9live.com (neutral report), hindustantimes.com (neutral report), m9.news (sensationalist), rediff.com (neutral report), khelnow.com (neutral report), rediff.com (2) (neutral report), indiatoday.in (neutral report), hindustantimes.com (2) (neutral report)
This brief was synthesised by AI from the 10 sources linked above, so one read covers every framing they carry. Methodology and corrections.