
Political parties in Jammu and Kashmir, excluding the BJP, have urged Speaker Abdul Rahim Rather to act against Chief Secretary Atal Dulloo and Law Secretary Achal Sethi for writing to the Speaker opposing the language of a statehood resolution moved by Chief Minister Omar Abdullah and adopted by the assembly on 28 September. PDP MLA Waheed Para moved a privilege motion against the two officers, who separately wrote to the Speaker questioning the resolution’s mention of an autonomy resolution passed in 2000. Congress legislator Irfan Hafiz Lone and National Conference’s Mubarakh Gul said the House should take serious note of an officer giving an opinion to the assembly.

BJP MLAs countered that the statehood resolution was unconstitutional and illegal. The Indian Express reports both Dulloo, a Kashmiri Pandit, and Sethi, a Dogra, are natives of J&K. Dulloo, a 1989-batch IAS officer, is retiring on 31 October. Farooq Abdullah on 2 October accused the BJP of wanting to enslave J&K. BJP MP Tarun Chugh on 3 October called the resolution an eyewash and said PM Modi remains committed to statehood. LoP Sunil Sharma told The Indian Express that Union Home Minister Amit Shah expressed displeasure over the resolution. The Speaker has received the privilege motion but not yet ruled on it. NC's Showkat Mir said on 3 October that the elected government is focused on public welfare and accused the BJP of negative propaganda.
NC leader Ajay Sadhotra said on 4 October that the BJP-led Centre had degraded J&K's status and deprived people of political rights. National Conference General Secretary Ali Muhammad Sagar said on 2 October that restoration of statehood was essential to strengthen the elected government's authority and ensure administrative accountability.
Update, 5 October 2026: NC leader Ajay Sadhotra said on 4 October that the BJP-led Centre degraded J&K's status and deprived people of political rights. NC General Secretary Ali Muhammad Sagar said on 2 October that statehood is essential for accountability. Kashmir Life and KNS Kashmir report these statements. The privilege motion remains pending before the Speaker.
The coverage splits along partisan lines. Pro-government outlets, including The Indian Express’s reporting of BJP leaders’ statements, emphasise that the resolution was unconstitutional and that Amit Shah expressed displeasure, framing the bureaucrats’ letters as legitimate administrative caution. NC-aligned sources such as Rising Kashmir and Kashmir Life foreground Farooq Abdullah’s accusation that the BJP wants to enslave J&K and argue the bureaucrats overreached. The Economic Times and Nagaland Post provide neutral wire-style summaries of the privilege motion. The balanced reading is that both sides agree on the core facts, the letters were sent and the motion was filed, but disagree on whether the officials acted within their mandate or undermined the legislature. The Speaker has not yet ruled on the privilege motion.
Coverage: 17 sources, 2 pro-government, 6 government-critical, 9 neutral
Sources (17): economictimes.indiatimes.com (neutral report), indianexpress.com (neutral report), risingkashmir.com (government critical), indianexpress.com (2) (neutral report), kashmirlife.net (government critical), risingkashmir.com (2) (government critical), indianexpress.com (3) (pro government), indianexpress.com (4) (neutral report), indianexpress.com (5) (neutral report), nagalandpost.com (neutral report), thehindu.com (pro government), indianexpress.com (6) (neutral report), indianexpress.com (7) (neutral report), risingkashmir.com (3) (government critical), indianexpress.com (8) (neutral report), kashmirlife.net (2) (government critical), knskashmir.com (government critical)
This brief was synthesised by AI from the 17 sources linked above, so one read covers every framing they carry. Methodology and corrections.