Mass disenfranchisement ‘intrinsically arbitrary’, says SC judge

The Story in Brief

Supreme Court Justice Ujjal Bhuyan on Sunday, 4 October, said any process that disenfranchises millions of Indian citizens is 'intrinsically arbitrary' and a negation of the constitutional order. Delivering the valedictory address at the 19th NALSAR-Justice BR Sawhney Memorial Moot Court Competition in Hyderabad, Justice Bhuyan said no amount of 'whataboutery' could justify taking away voting rights.

The judge said the Constitution does not create two classes of citizens, those with voting rights and those without. He stressed that any process leading to wholesale disenfranchisement would violate Articles 326 (adult suffrage) and 14 (equality). 'No authority can do it, no court can condone it. No one is above the Constitution,' he said. Justice Bhuyan also said the right to vote is central to the basic structure of the Constitution. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh said the remarks 'exposed' Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear petitions on the SIR process on 5 October.

Update, 5 October 2026: Justice Bhuyan said the right to vote is central to the basic structure of the Constitution and that no court can condone wholesale disenfranchisement. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh said the remarks 'exposed' Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear petitions on the SIR process on 5 October. Times of India, Economic Times and Times Now also reported the speech.

Indian Opinion Analysis

Justice Bhuyan's address is reported by every outlet as a constitutional critique of mass voter exclusion, with none contesting his core argument. Barandbench, LiveLaw, Hindustan Times and The Hindu lead with his full quotes, framing the speech as a direct challenge to the Election Commission's SIR exercise. Times of India and CNBC-TV18 also note the speech's timing a day before the Supreme Court hears petitions against CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The Congress, quoted in Times of India, uses the remarks to demand Kumar's resignation, a political reaction several outlets include but do not endorse. The Wire and The South First emphasise the scale of deletions (13 crore names). No outlet carries a government or EC counter-statement. The coverage is uniform in its straight reporting of the judge's words and the political fallout, the key open point is the 5 October hearing.

Coverage: 34 sources, 1 government-critical, 31 neutral, 2 sensationalist


Sources (34): barandbench.com (neutral report), livelaw.in (neutral report), hindustantimes.com (neutral report), timesnownews.com (sensationalist), cnbctv18.com (neutral report), timesofindia.indiatimes.com (neutral report), ndtv.com (neutral report), abplive.com (neutral report), deccanherald.com (neutral report), newindianexpress.com (neutral report), news9live.com (neutral report), deccanchronicle.com (neutral report), indianexpress.com (neutral report), thehindu.com (neutral report), odishabytes.com (neutral report), siasat.com (neutral report), nationalheraldindia.com (neutral report), ndtvprofit.com (neutral report), indiatvnews.com (neutral report), thefederal.com (neutral report), timesnownews.com (2) (sensationalist), aninews.in (neutral report), pragativadi.com (neutral report), indiatoday.in (neutral report), economictimes.indiatimes.com (neutral report), timesofindia.indiatimes.com (2) (neutral report), mathrubhumi.com (neutral report), thehansindia.com (neutral report), thesouthfirst.com (neutral report), newindianexpress.com (2) (neutral report), thewire.in (government critical), timesofindia.indiatimes.com (3) (neutral report), economictimes.indiatimes.com (2) (neutral report), timesnownews.com (3) (neutral report)

This brief was synthesised by AI from the 34 sources linked above, so one read covers every framing they carry. Methodology and corrections.

Update, 5 October 2026: further reports on this story from theprint.in, thefederal.com.

Update, 5 October 2026: further reports on this story from highlandpost.com, economictimes.indiatimes.com.

Ask their opinion on this story
They have read this article, our coverage, and the web.
AI simulations of historical figures. Responses are generated from the historical record, not authentic statements.

0 Votes: 0 Upvotes, 0 Downvotes (0 Points)

Share your opinion

Sign in to comment

Comments are open to readers with an Indian Opinion account. We email you a 6-digit code; there is no password.

Sign in to comment

Loading Next Post...
Search Trending
Ask their opinion
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...

All fields are required.