Now Reading: Madras HC: Police cannot block peaceful flag marches or protests
-
01
Madras HC: Police cannot block peaceful flag marches or protests
The Madras High Court ruled that citizens have a fundamental right to carry the national flag during peaceful rallies, and separately observed that police should not concern themselves with the content of a protest unless it violates reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) of the Constitution.
In a case filed by BJP's Coimbatore district president J Ramesh Kumar, Justice V Lakshminarayanan said on August 14 that displaying the tricolour is protected as freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a), and that police cannot arbitrarily restrict this right. The court permitted the flag yatra from MTP Road ARC Junction to North Kovai Chinthamani Junction on August 18.
The same judge on August 17 told the state it must not block a Dravida Kazhagam bike rally against NEET and EWS reservation. The court directed the party to furnish logistical details like venue, number of bikes and route for police bandobast, and adjourned the matter for fresh orders.
Indian Opinion Analysis
The Madras High Court has delivered two strong verdicts upholding the right to carry the national flag and the right to protest, but the coverage reveals contrasting editorial priorities. Barandbench.com focused on the court's scolding of police for obstructing a BJP flag yatra, quoting the judge's sarcastic remarks about inconvenience and emphasising the fundamental right under Articles 19(1)(a) and (b). The News Minute led with the court's oral observation that police should not concern themselves with the content of a protest, in the context of Dravida Kazhagam's bike rally against NEET and EWS reservation. While both rulings affirm similar constitutional principles, Barandbench implicitly privileged the nationalistic framing (flag, homage), and The News Minute the dissent framing (content neutrality). Neither outlet reported the actual rally outcomes from August 18, the date the BJP yatra was permitted. Watch for whether the Tamil Nadu government appeals either order in the Supreme Court, or grants permission to Dravida Kazhagam after details are submitted.
Coverage: 2 sources, 2 government-critical
Sources (2): barandbench.com (government critical), thenewsminute.com (government critical)
This story was synthesised by AI from the 2 sources linked above. Methodology and corrections.
Updated: this story now draws on 2 sources.
