Justice Bhuiyan: denying voting right is arbitrary, unconstitutional

The Story in Brief

Supreme Court Justice Ujjwal Bhuiyan said on Sunday, 4 October, that any process that deprives millions of Indian citizens of their right to vote is arbitrary and unconstitutional. Speaking at the NALSAR University of Law in Hyderabad, he said such a process violates Articles 326 and 14 of the Constitution. He stressed that no authority or court can justify this, and that the Constitution is above everyone.

SC Justice Ujjwal Bhuiyan calls voter disenfranchisement arbitrary

Justice Bhuiyan linked the right to vote to India's freedom struggle, calling it a central part of the basic structure doctrine. His remarks come as opposition parties and student groups in multiple cities protest the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter lists, demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. A petition against Kumar is scheduled for hearing in the Supreme Court on Monday, 5 October.

On Monday, 5 October, former Chief Justice BR Gavai and two retired Delhi High Court judges criticised Justice Bhuiyan's remarks, saying a sitting judge should not comment on a pending case. Congress spokesperson Jairam Ramesh said the CEC had lost all moral authority to stay in office.

Indian Opinion Analysis

The coverage splits between reporting the judge's remarks and reporting criticism of them. TV9 Hindi, Aaj Tak, Amar Ujala, Bhaskar and BBC quote Justice Bhuiyan's constitutional argument at length, linking it to the SIR controversy, but do not carry the retired judges' rebuttal. A separate Bhaskar article carries former CJI Gavai and two retired High Court judges saying a sitting judge should not comment on a pending matter, a view the other outlets omit. The uniform wire copy of the speech is straight reporting, the criticism is only in Bhaskar. The balanced reading is that while Justice Bhuiyan's remarks are widely covered as a statement of principle, a section of the legal fraternity has questioned their timing. The Supreme Court is to hear the SIR-related petition on 5 October.

Congress spokesperson Jairam Ramesh, quoted by Bhaskar, said the CEC had lost all moral authority.

Coverage: 6 sources, 6 neutral


Sources (6): tv9hindi.com (neutral report), aajtak.in (neutral report), amarujala.com (neutral report), bhaskar.com (neutral report), bbc.com (neutral report), bhaskar.com (2) (neutral report)

This brief was synthesised by AI from the 6 sources linked above, so one read covers every framing they carry. Methodology and corrections.

Update, 6 October 2026: this story now draws on 6 sources.

Ask their opinion on this story
They have read this article, our coverage, and the web.
AI simulations of historical figures. Responses are generated from the historical record, not authentic statements.

0 Votes: 0 Upvotes, 0 Downvotes (0 Points)

Share your opinion

Sign in to comment

Comments are open to readers with an Indian Opinion account. We email you a 6-digit code; there is no password.

Sign in to comment

Loading Next Post...
Search Trending
Ask their opinion
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...

All fields are required.