Now Reading: Resisting own medical exam is not obstructing public servant: SC
-
01
Resisting own medical exam is not obstructing public servant: SC
The Supreme Court has quashed an FIR against a Maharashtra forest department employee, ruling that resisting one's own medical examination does not amount to obstructing a public servant under Section 186 of…
The Supreme Court has quashed an FIR against a Maharashtra forest department employee, ruling that resisting one's own medical examination does not amount to obstructing a public servant under Section 186 of the IPC. A bench of Justices KV Viswanathan and Arun Palli set aside the Bombay High Court's Nagpur bench order that had refused to quash the case.
The appellant, a Lekhapal at the Forest Range Office in Paratwada, was arrested on May 4, 2021, for alleged intoxication and creating a disturbance. She was taken to Achalpur hospital for examination and initially resisted but later underwent the blood test. The Supreme Court held that since she eventually complied, her initial resistance did not fall within the meaning of 'voluntarily obstructs' under Section 186. The Court also rejected charges under Sections 189 IPC and 110, 112, and 117 of the Maharashtra Police Act, finding no ingredients of those offences were made out.
The ruling frees the appellant from criminal proceedings under the cause title Ashwini Anantrao Deshpande versus State of Maharashtra.
Indian Opinion Analysis
Section 186 IPC is a relatively rare charge from the colonial era, carrying a maximum six-month jail term. The Supreme Court's narrow reading matters because lower courts often routinise such arrests under the MP Act for minor public-order incidents. This ruling restores the distinction between initial reluctance and actual obstruction, a distinction that police frequently blur. The real impact will show in trial courts across Maharashtra, where magistrates now have fresh binding precedent to test similar FIRs. The petitioner, a state forest employee, also retains her job protection under the Maharashtra Civil Services Rules, which this criminal case had threatened.
Source: livelaw.in
This brief was synthesised by AI from the source linked above.
