Nancy Guthrie case draws criticism over inexperienced detectives, FBI role

The investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance six months ago faces dual pressure: a union leader claims the initial team lacked homicide experience, while the attorney general has rejected calls for the FBI to take over. Sergeant Aaron Cross, president of the Pima County Deputies Organization, told TMZ that some investigators had about three years of experience, calling them 'novice homicide detectives.' He said the lead sergeant was promoted into homicide from patrol in 2023 and alleged command transferred two senior detectives to cold cases after a dispute over an arrest. Cross described the release of the crime scene the day after Guthrie vanished, in his view, as a 'big misstep.'

Attorney General Todd Blanche told NBC News's 'Meet the Press' that the FBI taking over 'is not necessarily the right thing to do for her,' but said the bureau is providing manpower and forensic assistance. The search has been led by Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos, who has faced criticism from FBI Director Kash Patel for delaying the bureau's involvement, and reports of blood evidence overlooked and a late-deployed surveillance plane. President Donald Trump spoke with Savannah Guthrie in February, directing 'ALL Federal Law Enforcement' to assist. Nanos has said the case is not cold and that the department continues to work hard.