
Rajasthan civil rights groups have demanded a complete overhaul of the Supreme Court-appointed high-powered committee's hearing process on the Aravalli hill range, alleging it excludes affected communities. The People's Union for Civil…
Rajasthan civil rights groups have demanded a complete overhaul of the Supreme Court-appointed high-powered committee's hearing process on the Aravalli hill range, alleging it excludes affected communities. The People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL) and other organisations say the committee's four-day, nine-district tour is a 'token' exercise. They claim the mining lobby dominated hearings, particularly in Ajmer, where many mining operators were reportedly brought in to participate. The groups have sought a transparent process, a comprehensive study of all Aravalli districts, and direct assessments of mining-affected communities, including silicosis patients.
The rights bodies also criticised the committee's composition, noting its chairperson and two members are from the same department that earlier recommended only hills over 100 metres be considered part of the Aravallis. They have demanded the committee's tenure be extended and field visits to rural and mining-affected areas be conducted. The organisations warned that if the panel fails to ensure genuine participation, they will organise their own public hearings across the Aravalli region.
The demand for inclusive hearings is fair, but the rhetoric about a 'mining lobby' dominating the proceedings risks oversimplifying a complex land-use and conservation debate. The real test is not who speaks first, but whether the committee produces a science-based assessment that balances ecology with the livelihoods of communities dependent on these hills. Will the panel broaden its scope or remain trapped in a narrow, contested definition of what constitutes the Aravalli range?
Source: thehindu.com
This story was synthesised by AI from the source linked above.