Now Reading: AI can aid reasoning but not replace judicial conscience: CJI
-
01
AI can aid reasoning but not replace judicial conscience: CJI
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said AI can assist courts in legal research, translation and administration but must not determine judicial outcomes. Speaking during a bilateral meeting with German Federal Court…
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant said AI can assist courts in legal research, translation and administration but must not determine judicial outcomes. Speaking during a bilateral meeting with German Federal Court of Justice presiding judge Ulrich Herrmann, CJI Kant said artificial intelligence may augment judicial reasoning but cannot substitute judicial conscience.
Draft regulations prepared by the Supreme Court's AI Committee allow administrative uses of AI such as scheduling, transcription and translation, while barring its use for assessing witness credibility, flight risk, recidivism or bail eligibility. A permanent apex body has been proposed to oversee AI adoption and ensure accountability.
CJI Kant also proposed deeper judicial cooperation with Germany, including an MoU focused on technology in court administration, cross-border mediation and commercial dispute resolution, with each side to identify an institutional point of contact to convert the discussion into a workable programme.
Indian Opinion Analysis
The CJI's remarks come as the Indian judiciary processes over 5 crore pending cases across all tiers, with the Supreme Court alone carrying more than 80,000 cases. Technology is seen as a way to cut pendency without compromising judicial independence. The proposed permanent apex body for AI would mirror the model of other sectoral regulators and would need to balance efficiency gains against concerns over data privacy and algorithmic bias, which the Supreme Court flagged in the 2023 K S Puttaswamy reaffirmation. Watch for whether the proposed body is created through executive order or legislation, as the latter would allow parliamentary scrutiny.
The India-Germany MoU on judicial cooperation, if signed, would be among the first bilateral agreements to explicitly cover AI governance in courts. German courts already use electronic case files and a Federal Justice Cloud, offering a working template.
Source: indiatoday.in
This brief was synthesised by AI from the source linked above.
